What it's actually like
Overwhelmingly positive reviews praising exceptional pizza quality, impressive craft beer selection, and charming historic train depot setting with live music. Occasional concerns about pricing, service inconsistency, and noise levels during busy periods. Strong repeat customer base and destination appeal for visitors from surrounding areas.
historic train depotlive music venuecraft beer focusedlaid-back neighborhoodeclectic charm
Diners keep mentioning
Derailed pizzadeep-dish/Detroit-style pizzastuffed mushroomsloaded pretzel bitesgluten-free optionshouse-made beers (Peacock Pilsner, Lawn Chair creme ale, Coffee cream ale)
Ambiance
rustic-casual
Noise level
moderate
Dress code
casual
Outdoor seating
Yes
Good for
date night, family dining, girls night
Reservations
unknown
Wait reality — Reservations recommended on weekends and during live music events, as the space fills quickly. Wait times typically 15-30 minutes on busy Friday/Saturday nights. Best times to visit are weekday afternoons or early evenings.
Derived from 71 recent Google reviews — not marketing copy.
When to go
- Monday: Closed
- Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Thursday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Friday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Saturday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Sunday: Closed
What's cooking
Appetizer
Loaded Pretzel
Original pretzel cut into bite sized morsels covered in mozzarella, cheddar and bacon, baked until golden & served with a side of house made dill mustard
Pretzel & Mustardvegetarian
Large soft pretzel baked, salted & served with house made dill mustard
Reuben Rollups
10" Round stretched out and stuffed with sauerkraut, Corned beef, Swiss cheese & 1000 island dressing. Baked to a golden brown and sprinkled with caraway seeds on top. Served with a side of house made 1000 island dressing
Stuffed Mushroomsvegetarian
Mushroom caps filled with fresh garlic, Parmesan, herbs & Mozzarella cheese baked until bubbly. Served with a side of crispy baked bread (Gluten-Free when served without bread)
TPB Bread #1: The Originalvegetarian
10" round of fresh-baked pizza dough with fresh garlic, Mozzarella cheese & spices with warm red sauce for dipping
TPB Bread #2: Margheritavegetarian
10" round of fresh-baked pizza dough with fresh garlic, fresh tomatoes, basil & Mozzarella cheese
TPB Bread #3: Artichoke & Mozzarellavegetarian
10" round of fresh-baked pizza dough with fresh garlic, artichoke hearts, spinach & Mozzarella cheese
Salad
Bohemian Saladvegetarian
Fresh spring greens, red onions, red pepper, mushrooms, feta, sun-dried tomatoes, black olives & pepperoncini. Served with choice of house made vinaigrette, dill pickle vinaigrette, or ranch dressing and a side of bread
Side Saladvegetarian
Fresh spring greens, tomatoes, red onions, Cheddar & your choice of house made vinaigrette, dill pickle vinaigrette, or ranch dressing. Served with bread until 3 pm
Entree
6 inch Personal Pizza
Three toppings of your choice. Includes mozzarella cheese and house made red sauce
Build Your Own Pizza - 10 inch$14.95
10" pizza with choice of toppings
Build Your Own Pizza - 13 inch$19.95
13" pizza with choice of toppings
Build Your Own Pizza - 16 inch$27.95
16" pizza with choice of toppings
Calzone
Three toppings of your choice. Includes Mozzarella cheese and house made red sauce inside, and on the side for dippings!
Cauliflower Crust Pizzagluten free
Three toppings of your choice, includes Mozzarella cheese and house made red sauce served on the side (contains dairy)
Chicken Alfredo Pizza
House made alfredo sauce, broccoli, chicken, spinach & red pepper. Try adding bacon!
Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap
Chicken, Bacon, Cheddar nestled atop a bed of fresh Spinach and a drizzle of TPB Ranch. Served with Salad and Chips. Available from 12pm to 3pm
Chicken Parmesan Wrap
Roasted Chicken topped with TPB Sauce, smothered in Mozzarella, topped with Parmesan and Fresh Basil. Served with Salad and Chips. Available from 12pm to 3pm
★ Derailed Pizza
11 toppings: fresh garlic, spinach, pepperoni, salami, ham, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, house made spicy beer sausage, black olives & pepperoncini (cooked well done)
Garden Pizzavegetarian
Fresh garlic, mushrooms, onions, black olives, green peppers, spinach & pepperoncini
Mediterranean Pizzavegetarian
Fresh garlic, feta, spinach & sun-dried tomatoes
★ Pizza Diane
Pesto base topped with chicken, spinach, feta cheese & cherry tomatoes
★ TPB Special Pizza
Spicy beer sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions and green peppers
Veggiemania Wrapvegetarian
TPB Pesto, Fresh Spinach, Tomatoes, Feta, Red Peppers, and Red Onions. Served with Salad and Chips. Available from 12pm to 3pm
Dessert
★ Burntwood Black Brownievegetarian
A decadent fudgy brownie made with our house brewed Burntwood Black
Cheesecake Bitesvegetarian
Ask your server for our current selection
Cheesecake Plattervegetarian
Three varieties of cheesecake bites on one platter
Root Beer Floatvegetarian
Sprechers Root Beer with a scoop of Ice Cream
Vanilla Ice Creamvegetarian
Single scoop
Find it
Address
1615 Winter St, Superior, WI
Phone
(715) 394-2500
Restaurant group
independent